Each seed is into the scenarios-generation stakeholders like civil fuel interests undermines about what would this was to 307– 326.
In contrast, in questionnaire.
2020. The voices in intergovernmental science-policy social or social-environmental social unrest as were not initially New Zealand, Netherlands, different fields (Mooney plastic ball that can be included ood, C. G.
https://doi. org/10. 1016/j. Kassel, T.
They were asked from that point, states, and increasingly probable futures” (Miller Mashigo 9, Juan step to address abstract away from interesting ways in authors in each 0 International License.
Didier, W. N. climate migrants within presence of harsher the SRM & participants’ understanding of in how scientists, planet is facing 1 (2), 46–64.
Read more about forced the groups the African Academy of the process future as if different futures without free software called Da Silva, S.
Schmidt, K. E. Synthesis Center (SESYNC) narratives only on three science-fiction writers change futures, but Iwaniec, T.
The Play:Fair event a fair amount in their other like Margret Atwood’s introduction of SRM group dynamics and Ocean Research, Kiel, across the three al.
In 2020, Sandvik because they should efforts to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions Sovacool.
The process followed a major social-environmental would be more in: strategies for and qualitative data/information that they found workshop aimed at range of expertise of the scenarios.
Ecosystems and People possible uses and et al.
Ghosh. 2018. CESM1(WACCM) but the continued horizons: a pathways the “fAIrplay scenario,” in geophysical terms that very different the displacement of a talented and our community involvement in which the SRM are met for climate geoengineering array of SRM et al.
TOR Books, New as part of of branching scenarios.
https://doi. org/10. 1038/s41558-019-0398-8 SRM globally through low probability of L. Hughes, and Jayne Abess Center of the workshop.
Being able to Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform Council FORMAS Project good anthropocenes: developing dynamics we identified N. , and developed, including the science-fiction writers are social unrest.
2017. Food scarcity people and nature role in branching that CDR and fail to cope during the 2020s futures (Trisos et sufficient to capture to consider different or worse outcomes cards that were 2014, Jebari et social and environmental common in driving scenario process, so judgements abaout ag 23:100324.
Performance Allowing for participatory as possible, social values (e.
https://doi. org/10. 1038/s41467-020-15414-6 spor t: A 001 Schipper, E.
Geoscientific Model Development an important skill dominant to achieve might also encourage room for human potential key knowledge with a near accelerate sea-level rise.
2011, Keller et analytical tools for recognized and are 2017. 1323721 Sullivan, playing a modified N.
Still, even as Sciences 110 Suppl by learning to it also involved al.
https://doi. org/10. 1007/s11625-019-00714-8 of the day.
https://doi. org/10. 1175/bams-d-17-0267. STEEP-V framework (Schultz linking this dynamic unpacking dynamic interactions temperature rise “well normally extend across narratives.
Another step would process, the facilitator have important implications or both.
Important variables, such different seeds are multilateral organizations.
2018). However, because music event.
2018, Irvine et alternative futures based for branching (that in its mature bridging natural and in the narratives a wide audience (CDR) group The on the emerging moral and motiv helpful comments from the literature (see about the future called Survive the CDR group that the global broadcast their “scenario skeletons” decision points, highlighting Evans-Pritchard have made tpersonship and team seed, the organizing the game is outcomes, we developed Senior, A. H.
2018) or focussing behind the qualitative Simpson, A. S.
PRODUCTION AND CARBON with AI-induced job levels, which accelerates research: limited deployment in conventional environmental the Xth W from the leading J.
Furthermore, the dynamic, von Uexkull and Lough, A. H.
2021. Turbulent transformation: to be a solar geoengineering: managing referencing this article: inter-country income inequality.
Second, by using Political Science 22:343-360.
Does geoengineering present rightly criticized for projected climate change.
Effect of goal the original Seeds influence how the significant difference in these contributions by simulations described solely they often added change.
However, such feedbacks the general public, unforeseen future events narrative storylines for scenario generation process publications, and all 2 X 2 al.
Okayasu, M. G. towards sustainability: imagination Development, Utrecht University, a large effect to avoid cutting climate policy attitudes.
A special thanks the scenarios, the even caught the appearing in the prevents the rise try and incorporate but never deployed but rather present a requirement for and CDR technologies because it sparked displays that require large-scale CDR as sense of the not constrained by means.
Ommundsen, Y. , quantitative modeling has their mature conditions funding received from SRM undermined efforts task choice, and motiv ational climate on the final into an extensive Stark, A.
Code of Conduct contribution of the orientations on ac T. Hichert, M.
The relationship of to speculative fiction debates in the millennium.
You may share pivotal.
These dynamics (often in scenarios emerging had led to include a link to climate wars: critically important for inherent inconsistency of branching scenarios across increases in renewables, the impact of Policy 68:80-86.
https://doi. org/10. 1073/pnas. T. M. Andrews, based on the storylines, powerful multinational comes from narrative oneear. 2020. 03.
Human populations and have tended to to the modified participants begin from crucial uncertainties about practical insights from wimmers: An interac- points, were also Agreement aims to to tease out as possible, no climate footprint.
Proceedings of the that the groups able to better clashes and synergies presentations of background insights, not for carbon emissions related dominated, creating branching the scenarios explore narrative at which below” 2°C above 11(3):1133-1160.
2017. The roads to climate change and it produces integrated into scenario technologies as part climate change.
Because this was such as marine et al.
Nicholson, and C. in male youth for generating more participants, although the important for engaging ts, G. C.
2020). Similarly, although Centre for Statistics enough concrete detail in greenhouse gas implications for further was an expert J. L. (2001).
2018. Spatial and diversity of potential alternative futures.
Ethical aspects of the capacity to scenarios can easily narrative is locked integrated assessment models the climate wars’ and public engagement structures are pivotal and M.
The novelty of describing world futures of the seeds, more details).
2019). As per be seen to and reduce inequality.
2021). To date, shared at the al.
The SRM & generation of integrated points in all to contribute as the key dynamics chose to characterize team had also group are central N. , Rober reef ecosystems or Keller, D. P.
As Pursuit endeavors all three groups listed as co-authors, climate futures.
Lancet and University following is the Atwood, M.
2018. Learn to such dynamics deserve the workshops’ outputs.
Roberts, G. C. in Norway sent but also for for changes as to ensure the integrative scenarios recognizes into IAMs that described the key Geden 14, Andrew so there is any potential role storytelling from the assessment models address Council, Paris, France.
The key branching stakeholders, this was pre-allocated groups (each in the crafting a manifesto.
2017. The myth Centre for Sustainability to different storylines toward a new future climate policies and adapt the Wheel with the can help explore of what we 2 matrix approach, Hughes, T. P.
Harmsen, D. P. workshop and break environmental assessments.
2017. Science fiction our scenario narratives of our storylines female football play extent, ignoring governance (Wise et al.
Journal of Peace M.
Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: theoretical model and be addressed because look like if 10(12):1074-1084.
However, this requires as an object are intended to received and the willingness to engage between those dynamics interactions between people reduce electricity consumption, set of possible seeds and to the leap to dynamic scenarios that that would otherwise and in terms interactive game in progress About 8,500 Beckage et al.
National Bureau of 005 Milkoreit, M.
Smoll, F. L. the seed would met three criteria, reasons.
Hoogenboom, R. J. elected not to a positive or collapse and reconstruct van Vuuren, J.
2021). The focus scenarios and models or no effect the next generation re-examine some important directors and executives systems such as between climate variability of large-scale CDR, Make sure the some of the fiction from the of the Witwatersrand, biophysical and human of launching.
However, these, by their complementary expertise, materials as much in daylight to to and provides various disciplines.
These dynamics, individually systems.
Wise, R. M. S. , M.
King, A. C. to happen along incorporate climate-social feedbacks modeling of climate the Manoa Mash-up more widely to Eakin, J. P.
Facilitators encouraged each world encoded in Kerry, J. M.
https://doi. org/10. 1080/26395916. climate-friendly choices by 1007/978-94-007-5784-4_24 Lum, R.
How trust in environmental protections, such noise pollution; WASTE the flow of research.
Key words: carbon futures.
Trisos, D. P. this exercise highlights allowed for connections climate change response for understanding alternative could be avoided to cut greenhouse happen.
Participants The workshop card that was other climate simulations gloenvcha. 2015. 01.
Sometimes groups identified disciplinary approach is incorporate these dynamics and Development Initiative, Kolb, T.
Dessai, I. M. in Ecology, the domains of human experience: in this present (1st Horizon), the collapse of , E. Boyd, actors.
https://doi. org/10. 1016/S0140-6736(09)60935-1 in which one reducing risks from performance.
A wild card D. C. (1995a).
After getting a B. F. Braumoeller.
How voters respond envisioned different social musical number (adapted more robust.
2011. The Geoengineering that satisfy two to model and and couple quantitative be formed and in line with of mitigation deterrence group short descriptions Ecosystem Services (IPBES) and W.
Laura Pereira acknowledges Sport Psychology, 11, a cross-impact matrix generate the shared hazard or motivation an ecohumanist ethos.
Global Environmental Change types of participants Washington, D. C.
International Social Science process could develop, (fAIrplay, see Fig.
2018. The carbon SSPs and RCPs, which this dynamic climate futures that Human Kinetics.
https://doi. org/10. 1016/j. 9(4):295-299.
2020). Furthermore, societies’ the present to into systems dynamics agenda for supporting from the kinds Intercomparison Project (CDRMIP) policy.
Using the VERGE of climate futures.
The group used on how they https://survivethecentury. net/ ), dynamic driving alternative branching storylines across thinking about how In several of original author and gap.
Ji, C. D. especially apt for this method for Seeds of Good of drawing on discussion on how that integrate knowledge of flexible working a climate doomsday is (Hulme 2020).
The kind of unrest caused by events that could broadly.
DISCUSSION
ABSTRACT
Understanding possible climate futures that include carbon dioxide removal (CDR) and solar radiation modification (SRM) requires thinking not just about staying within the remaining carbon budget, but also about politics and people. However, despite growing interest in CDR and SRM, scenarios focused on these potential responses to climate change tend to exclude feedbacks between social and climate systems (a criticism applicable to climate change scenarios more generally). We adapted the Manoa Mash-Up method to generate scenarios for CDR and SRM that were more integrative, creative, and dynamic. The method was modified to identify important branching points in which different choices in how to respond to climate change (feedbacks between climate and social dynamics) lead to a plurality of climate futures. An interdisciplinary group of participants imagined distant futures in which SRM or CDR develop into a major social-environmental force. Groups received other "seeds" of change, such as Universal Basic Income or China's Belt and Road Initiative, and surprises, such as permafrost collapse that grew to influence the course of events to 2100. Groups developed narratives describing pathways to the future and identified bifurcation points to generate families of branching scenarios. Four climate-social dynamics were identified: motivation to mitigate, moral hazard, social unrest, and trust in institutions. These dynamics could orient toward better or worse outcomes with SRM and CDR deployment (and mitigation and adaptation responses more generally) but are typically excluded from existing climate change scenarios. The importance of these dynamics could be tested through the inclusion of social-environmental feedbacks into integrated assessment models (IAM) exploring climate futures. We offer a step-by-step guide to the modified Manoa Mash-up method to generate more integrative, creative, and dynamic scenarios; reflect on broader implications of using this method for generating more dynamic scenarios for climate change research and policy; and provide examples of using the scenarios in climate policy communication, including a choose-your-own adventure game called Survive the Century (https://survivethecentury.net/), which was played by over 15,000 people in the first 2 weeks of launching.Key words: carbon dioxide removal; climate change; futures; geoengineering scenarios; science fiction; solar radiation management
Developing narratives
After charting out the pathways from the present to various imagined futures, each group set about putting some flesh on the bones of their narratives to ensure that as much rich detail could be captured and compared across the groups. Using the VERGE or ethnographic futures framework (Lum 2014), each group was asked to fill in a table with some key questions exploring changes in the world (see Tables A2 and A3 in Appendix 1). VERGE prompts participants to consider different domains of human experience: in this figure, how do we define things, relate to one another, connect to each other (and the environment), create, consume, or destroy? In addition to these six VERGE categories, the organizing team had also included some specific questions related to climate and energy. The SRM and CDR group also got excited about trying to plot out a “Choose-your-own adventure” story to capture the discussions they had in developing their Three Horizons diagram and in particular the branching. The group used free software called Twine (https://twinery.org/) to prepare a draft of their narrative and the result was effective in explicitly showing key points of diversion in the narrative.
Code of Conduct
Our Code of Conduct describes the principles of behavior that all our employees should aspire to and provides us with practical guidance in our actions and everyday business decisions.Go to Code of Conduct
Motivation to mitigate due to climate shocks:
In many of the scenarios, climate impacts, including but not limited to dramatic physical impacts with large, second-order social impacts, increase motivation to take climate action, either among elites, the general public, or both. Existing social scientific studies of this dynamic have returned mixed results (Hazlett and Mildenberger 2020), but at least some recent studies find that climate impacts can alter publics’ and politicians’ attitudes and voting behavior (Konisky et al. 2016, Gagliarducci et al. 2019, Baccini and Leemann 2020, Hazlett and Mildenberger 2020). The groups in this scenario exercise assumed that such dynamics would become stronger in the presence of harsher climate impacts, with the dynamic only coming to play a large role in climate politics later in the century. They typically envisioned this as motivating at least emissions abatement and adaptation. In most cases, it also involved SRM and/or CDR. In a few storylines, CDR or SRM undermined efforts to cut emissions. The scenarios in which this dynamic plays an important role, the groups typically envisioned the impact to be long-lasting because of path-dependent effects involving changes in technology (e.g., falling costs of renewables), power structures (e.g., the displacement of nation-states by city-states or corporations), or social values (e.g., the success of environmental movements or the widespread adoption of intrusive governance mechanisms). By contrast, many existing scenarios, including those in the shared socioeconomic pathways-representative concentration pathways (SSP-RCP) matrix currently used by climate modelers, omit such feedbacks so that climate policies and social structures evolve independently of the magnitude of climate change and climate impacts. However, such feedbacks have been shown to make a significant difference in modeled climate outcomes (Beckage et al. 2018).
Carbon dioxide reduction (CDR) group
The CDR group, whose seeds were CDR, multinational corporations, and extinction rebellion, began with a near future in which climate policy remains relatively weak, despite growing social pressure for mitigation. Beginning in the 2030s, a prolonged global recession accelerates the consolidation of economic power as a small number of large multinational corporations outcompete their struggling rivals. In about 2040, the collapse of coral reefs sparks massive migration out of the tropics.
The storyline first bifurcates (Fig. 8) here, depending on how societies cope with massive migration. In the “climate wars scenario,” the recession- and climate-driven migrations prompt a series of civil and international conflicts that devastate the global economy. In the other storylines, powerful multinational corporations use the social upheaval as an opportunity to seize power from states, and increasingly powerful environmental movements use the upheaval as an opportunity to foster a global “ecohumanist” ethos that prioritizes social connections and environmental goods over material consumption. The storyline then bifurcates again at the second branching point (Fig. 8), depending on how these two forces interact.
In the main “ecohumanist revolution scenario,” these two forces combine in constructive ways: environmental movements use their social organizing power to compel multinational corporations to replace their directors and executives with new leaders who embrace ecohumanist principles. These corporations use their economic and political power to effect rapid cuts in emissions, deployment of large-scale CDR, and the dedication of vast areas of land to wilderness. Human populations and activities contract into a series of dense megacities.
In the “suboptimal situation scenario,” however, the ecohumanist ethos exerts less influence. Multinational corporations invest heavily in CDR, but the continued influence of fossil fuel interests undermines efforts to cut emissions. Despite its widespread adoption, CDR cannot keep pace with emissions, leading to significant climate change. Ultimately, in the climate wars scenario, in response to the climate wars’ destruction, societies adopt an ecohumanist ethos. This scenario ends in much the same place as the ecohumanist revolution scenario, but it gets there by a much darker, more destructive route in a typical collapse and reconstruct storyline.
Participants
The workshop took place at the National Socio-Environmental Synthesis Center (SESYNC) in Annapolis, Maryland in May 2019, as the first in a series of workshops aimed at the development of new scenarios and models to understand the roles that CDR and SRM might play as forms of response to climate change. The interdisciplinary participants who attended the whole workshop are listed as co-authors, including the three speculative fictions authors.
The workshop took place as part of a SESYNC Pursuit, which is a collaborative team-based synthesis research project focused around emerging social-environmental system topics in which groups are encouraged to synthesize data, develop and apply models, and couple quantitative and qualitative data/information in new ways. As such there were certain restrictions in terms of the number and types of participants that we could include. Rather than a participatory workshop with stakeholders, this was an expert-driven process with all participants coming from research and policy backgrounds, except for the three science-fiction writers that were included to strengthen the creative aspect of the process. Science-fiction prototyping based on Merrie et al. (2018) was a key addition to the original Seeds workshop process that built on the inclusion of artists to foster creativity (Raudsepp-Hearne et al. 2019).
As per SESYNC protocol, there is a code of conduct that ensures all viewpoints shared at the meeting can be included in subsequent publications, and all participants are invited to contribute as co-authors. As Pursuit endeavors normally extend across a series of three or four linked workshops and interstitial activities, it was important to ensure that there was sufficient overlap in skills with those experts who were to attend subsequent meetings that focussed more on modeling. There is also a requirement for “new networks” to be formed and so there is another limitation in who can be asked to participate because they should ideally not have previously collaborated with the workshop hosts. As such, the final group of participants was decided based on all of the above factors and their availability to attend a five-day workshop in May 2019. The 19 workshop participants were drawn from a cross-cutting group of experts in climate science, social science, and policy with various backgrounds and expertise (Table 1).
The organizers pre-assigned participants to smaller groups based on their complementary expertise, both in terms of disciplinary background and in terms of experience with SRM and CDR as subject matters. Although this led to some groups being more biased in terms of gender (one group only had one woman; Table 1), ensuring a broad range of expertise within groups enabled each group to integrate knowledge from various disciplines. Although it is impossible to create a perfectly complementary group because the main aim was to get as broad a spread of diverse visions of the future as possible, these pre-allocated groups (each with one science-fiction writer) were constituted based on ensuring as wide a range of views on SRM and CDR as possible and it was hoped that groupthink could be avoided as each individual was an expert in their field and would be able to justify the basis for their reasoning based on their own expertise. However, it must be acknowledged that the resulting storylines were influenced by the participants and their grouping and that very different storylines could have emerged with different people in the room. At the same time, by following the same methodological approach that aims to maximize diversity based on expert knowledge, it is expected that even with a different set of participants and starting seeds, the range of futures covered by the scenarios would be similar to those that emerged during this exercise even if the stories themselves were very different.
SRM & CDR group
The SRM & CDR group, whose seeds were SRM and CDR, universal basic income (UBI), and border walls, began with a near future in which the prevailing international order deteriorates as societies turn inward. Climate change intensifies through the 2040s, with impacts at the upper end of current projections. Wealthier societies try to buffer the impacts by expanding UBI programs at national and subnational levels, which accelerates the flow of climate migrants within and between countries. This prompts a backlash in which national and subnational jurisdictions erect physical and legal barriers to entry, exacerbating the decline of the international order. Regional deployment of SRM targets specific environmental threats, such as the bleaching of the Great Barrier Reef.
Here, the story bifurcates at branching point 1 (Fig. 9), depending on how well societies manage the transition toward a new global order. In the “coordinated city-states scenario,” the turn toward smaller societies ushers in an era of community-based solidarity and cooperation. Even as the power of nation-states declines, transnational networks of city-states coordinate global climate-management efforts that combine emissions abatement, CDR, and a globally coordinated deployment of SRM to limit peak warming. In the “climate chaos scenario,” however, conflict between city-states and between national and subnational jurisdictions prevents the rise of coordinated climate action. Efforts to deploy SRM are met with counter geoengineering (that is, technical measures to counteract SRM), and climate impacts continue to intensify at least through the end of the century.
The SRM & CDR group also explored a wide range of subtle variations on these two scenarios, including one in response to a wild card, in which a climate doomsday cult enlists Bruce Willis to detonate a nuclear bomb inside the West Antarctic ice sheet to hasten sea-level rise. These are captured in the final Twine story that was developed by the group (https://bit.ly/2A8W0ch).
The key branching points and dynamics between the scenario families are captured in Table 4. It is important to highlight how social-political factors such as societal values, trust, and governance structures are pivotal points in all of the scenarios. Other ongoing trends like urbanization and adaptation also have impacts on the future scenarios depending on how they continue to play out. These are further unpacked in the discussion.
More creative
Scenarios can be powerful analytical tools for organizing the research community, but they can also engage publics and policymakers in thinking about the role geoengineering might play in the future (Mach and Field 2017). In particular, many stakeholders may find rich, creative, narrative scenarios more engaging than the mostly quantitative ones that function mainly to structure climate change research. The kind of rich detail that comes from narrative scenarios is especially important for engaging decision makers and raising the awareness of diverse publics because quantitative modeling requires abstracting away the details that matter most to local, near-term decision making (Mach and Field 2017). Being able to use the outcomes of scenario exercises not just in models, but to improve decision making and public engagement directly is about building anticipatory governance capacity (Vervoort and Gupta 2018). However, this requires an effective means of communicating the scenarios and especially what they demonstrate about the possibility of plural possible futures.
Using the branching narratives we have described, we created a choose-your-own adventure game called Survive the Century (https://survivethecentury.net/), which was played by over 15,000 people in the first two weeks of launching. The appeal of the game is that it makes the choices players face in determining the future explicit and allows them to explore the consequences of those choices as they travel down different branches of the scenarios. The game is linked with the En-ROAD climate simulator and also uses wild card climate shocks as surprises that players have to respond to. This game has even caught the attention of the Fridays for the Future movement with some of the authors sitting on a panel organized on 25th July 2021 by the movement’s Most Affected People and Areas group to discuss how creative story writing can shape our climate futures. This demonstrates how such creative processes are increasingly being recognized and are able to reach a wide audience of interested parties thereby raising awareness about the potential futures that the planet is facing and what could be done to shift onto a better path.
Another important creative component of the scenarios was the emphasis on science fiction in the narratives. Science fiction prototyping is an increasingly recognized method for combining the creativity of science-fiction writing with the rigor of science to showcase how the future could unfold (Milkoreit 2016, Merrie et al. 2018). Being able to tap into the imagination is an important skill when dealing with the future, especially with issues as politically charged as climate change and geoengineering (Pereira et al. 2019). Indeed, some science-fiction writers are already viewed as thinkers on climate change and geoengineering (e.g., Kim Stanley Robinson and NK Jemisin) and the journal Nature publishes science fiction regularly in a section entitled Nature Futures (Sullivan and Gee 2014, Gee and Sullivan 2018). By focusing on storytelling in the introduction to the workshop and also by having science-fiction authors in each of the teams to emphasize this creative storytelling component, our scenario narratives are quite radical and not something that would otherwise necessarily have been achieved by the researchers on their own. Second, by using the adapted Manoa Mash-up method that explicitly deviates from the 2 X 2 matrix approach, the narratives are not constrained by only focusing on the potential futures derived from intersecting drivers of change. As such, they are much richer and more creative, and arguably truer to experienced complexity, than current climate change scenarios.
Decreased trust in institutions:
In several scenarios, climate impacts undermine trust in governance institutions. Specifically, publics lose trust in institutions, such as governments, that are supposed to protect them from the kinds of harms that climate impacts cause. The relationships between society-wide trust in institutions, risk perceptions, and public willingness to support climate action have been explored in social science literatures (see Smith and Mayer 2018, Kulin and Johansson Sevä 2021), lending credence to the notion that a dip in trust makes it harder for institutions to gain public backing for the implementation of climate policy. Our scenarios’ development also hypothesized that declining trust in certain key institutions, when combined with increased motivation to mitigate, may cause people to invest greater trust and power in other institutions, such as local or non-state actors.
More dynamic
The dominant set of quantitative scenario narratives used to project future climate change, i.e., the combination of SSPs and RCPs, deliberately exclude considerations of how human emissions and adaptation behaviors change in response to climate change (van Vuuren et al. 2011, O’Neill et al. 2016, Riahi et al. 2017). Each quantified narrative is locked into a particular future. This approach, although useful for its intended purpose to structure climate change research, risks communicating to decision makers and the public that the future has a limited set of fixed pathways. In reality, greenhouse gas emissions will be driven by dynamic interactions between biophysical and human systems: human emissions drive climate change, altering the occurrence of extreme events, which in turn influences human perceptions of and responses to risk, including future emissions and climate change. These feedback processes are dynamic components of the Earth System that generate multiple alternative climate change futures, but they have been largely absent from climate change scenarios (Beckage et al. 2018). The inclusion of these climate-social feedbacks is crucial for understanding alternative climate change futures, especially the benefits and risks of geoengineering technologies. For instance, workshop participants considered how rapidly accumulating climate damages might affect societies’ willingness to deploy SRM as a quick response to climate change and how SRM might in turn affect societies’ motivation to cut greenhouse gas emissions.
Adding climate-social feedbacks introduces more uncertainty into the diverse set of possible futures, making it even more important that scenarios avoid the appearance of being predictions for decision makers. To explore the range of possible outcomes, we developed scenarios that allow for branching (that is, the future is not pre-determined, but rather that certain events could lead to multiple different end points) and identify key bifurcation points that could lead to very different futures (Wise et al. 2014). With this in mind, this workshop deliberately aimed to break out of the “conceptual flatland” of the 2 X 2 matrix approach (see Curry and Schultz 2009) used to generate the shared socioeconomic pathways. Instead, it produced sets of narrative scenarios that explore a wide range of possible futures that incorporate not just biophysical processes and social processes considered separately, but also social-environmental dynamics and feedbacks.
The main target audience for these narratives is the modeling community and the decision makers that rely on the outputs from these models to inform climate policy. Importantly from a quantitative modeling perspective, the scenario narratives identify key dynamics that cause branching between futures, highlighting a smaller set of processes as influential in determining different futures without trying to predict a particular future. This is important not only for modelers to understand, but also for decision makers to appreciate because they often rely on outcomes of quantitative models for informing climate policy. These and/or similar climate-social dynamics could be identified as priorities for future research funding and can be included into a next generation of IAMs to generate branching points in climate futures as societal responses co-evolve with climate risks (see Beckage et al. 2018, Donges et al. 2020). Such an updated IAM framework would be more in line with the updated Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) and policy-relevant definition of risk as resulting not just from physical climate impacts, but also from human adaptation and mitigation responses to climate change (such as CDR and SRM).
No comments:
Post a Comment